Skin issues on my upper lip
Forum rules
This section is for posts that are directly related to performance, performers, or equipment. Social issues are allowed, as long as they are directly related to those categories. If you see a post that you cannot respond to with respect and courtesy, we ask that you do not respond at all.
This section is for posts that are directly related to performance, performers, or equipment. Social issues are allowed, as long as they are directly related to those categories. If you see a post that you cannot respond to with respect and courtesy, we ask that you do not respond at all.
- matt g
- Posts: 2580
- Joined: Thu Aug 13, 2020 10:37 am
- Location: Southeastern New England
- Has thanked: 263 times
- Been thanked: 554 times
Re: Skin issues on my upper lip
If you’re ever in a situation where the rim is like that and you have no choices readily at hand, clear nail polish can offer temporary protection from the exposed brass.
Dillon/Walters CC (sold)
Meinl-Weston 2165 (sold)
Meinl-Weston 2165 (sold)
- Mary Ann
- Posts: 3029
- Joined: Thu Aug 13, 2020 9:24 am
- Has thanked: 517 times
- Been thanked: 598 times
Re: Skin issues on my upper lip
I don't think the fact that my body isn't good at getting rid of toxins is decreasing my lifespan very much....but it sure is making the end of that lifespan miserable. And I know SO many people in the same boat. Probably the only reason I'm still here is the incredible extent I go to, to keep from getting more crap in me and to get rid of the crap I have. Some who come in with what I call "good genetics" don't reach their tipping point nearly as soon as I did, and they don't have to suffer the misery until later in life. Modern medicine is good at a couple of things.....fixing when we actually break ourselves, and killing pathogens. But it is blind to illness caused by toxins and there are thousands upon thousands living with conditions that can't be fixed with either of these approaches. Sanitation has made a huge difference too.....but look at the incredible number of cancer cases out there. For a large number of cancers, the Gerson therapy is curative, and all it does is clear toxins. There are some it can't cure but it can and has cured, for example, stage 4 pancreatic cancer. But...it cannot be practiced in the US because our culture does not accept it, we having been enculturated with the concept that drugs and surgery are the answer. If I had only done what the allopaths said, I would not be here.
- bloke
- Mid South Music
- Posts: 19301
- Joined: Thu Aug 13, 2020 8:55 am
- Location: western Tennessee - near Memphis
- Has thanked: 3845 times
- Been thanked: 4091 times
- Rick Denney
- Resident Genius
- Posts: 1032
- Joined: Thu Aug 13, 2020 8:24 am
- Has thanked: 57 times
- Been thanked: 335 times
Re: Skin issues on my upper lip
The issue is with the brittleness of the coating. You want “toughness”. The gym floor coating is tough—it has to be significantly misshapen before it tears or cracks. This was a big advantage of polyurethane varnish over traditional varnish. brittle materials crack before they yield—bending a piece of glass (brittle) like a coat hanger breaks it before it will stay deformed.bloke wrote:I'm not responding to BobEuph in this post...Feel free to contact me and chat as you've done before...
===================
It occurred to me that someone might ask,
"Why not titanium-coat brass rims?"
In my experience, coating a really soft material with a really hard one doesn't work out very well.
Think of those "axial flow" trombone F-attachment valves, which are made of aluminum.
They are often titanium-coated, to prevent corrosion...but (often, within a very few years) the titanium coating fails.
I suspect that constant rubbing causes the hard coating to disengage from the soft base metal...
This is an extreme example, but think of "applying a super-tough polyurethane coating to some dried hard clay soil".
========================================
...In my house, the flooring is VERY wide (stunning) Vermont pine planks...but those pine planks are VERY soft, and scratch WAY too easily.
My plan is to sand down the floor and apply a product called "Gym Seal" (a super-tough gymnasium floor finish), but my concern - regarding durability - is precisely the type of concern expressed just above.
And it’s the problem with nitrocellulose lacquer used on brass—it’s too brittle and eventually cracks even from (presumably) thermal expansion. It is quite hard but lacks toughness.
Titanium nitride is a brittle ceramic, despite its hardness, and that’s why it is used on stiff substrates like steel (which is twice as stiff as brass). Metallic titanium itself is not brittle (though it is softer than steel), but the coatings on your mouthpieces are titanium nitride, not metallic titanium.
I have a watch (a modern Zodiac) that has a titanium nitride PVD coating. It’s gorgeous—looks exactly like 18k rose gold. But it will eventually wear on the sharp corners even on a stainless steel substrate, so one has to be careful. Even if a mouthpiece is coated with a hard treatment like titanium nitride, it should not be put where the rim gets rubbed against hard, rough surfaces (laminate floors are the worst). (Gold is softer than steel, but it’s tough, so it will conform to any dent inflicted on the steel without peeling. But it will also wear off eventually because of softness.)
The titanium nitride on hard steel drill bits eventually wears off, even when only used to drill wood (though i usually lose the drill bit before that happens).
Rick “wearing thin” Denney
- bloke
- Mid South Music
- Posts: 19301
- Joined: Thu Aug 13, 2020 8:55 am
- Location: western Tennessee - near Memphis
- Has thanked: 3845 times
- Been thanked: 4091 times
Re: Skin issues on my upper lip
sidebar:
Coating those aluminum trombone valves with titanium seems to me to be a bit like painting a ball of clay with epoxy paint.
—————————-
I suspect the durability and life of the titanium coating on surfaces - that are strong enough effectively to support it - depends on the angle at which the ions are blasted at an item. I suspect that not very many of them hit the corners of your watch, whereas they hit the round/symmetrical rim of a mouthpiece pretty darn evenly. (At first, I expected this titanium coating stuff to eventually show wear and begin to fail on these rims, but I’ve just never seen it…at least: not yet.) Due to how a cup of a mouthpiece is shaped, I’ve seen titanium coating failure down in there, which is why I’m not willing to coat the cups for customers. Further, it seems to me that the only practical reason for coating is for people who have really serious nickel allergies, as there is a 8% - 15% nickel in stainless steel (depending on the alloy). The face touches the rim. It’s difficult to imagine how a face could easily/routinely touch a mouthpiece cup interior. The main reason people ask for those coatings, though, is obviously for looks. Cups look like silver, and (the one particular color of) titanium coatings that we use on the rims looks like gold… except except they stay shiny, are extremely resistant to wear, and are resistant to scratching.
bloke “Titanium coatings can be applied in all sorts of wild colors, as has been seen on sports equipment and other things.”
Coating those aluminum trombone valves with titanium seems to me to be a bit like painting a ball of clay with epoxy paint.
—————————-
I suspect the durability and life of the titanium coating on surfaces - that are strong enough effectively to support it - depends on the angle at which the ions are blasted at an item. I suspect that not very many of them hit the corners of your watch, whereas they hit the round/symmetrical rim of a mouthpiece pretty darn evenly. (At first, I expected this titanium coating stuff to eventually show wear and begin to fail on these rims, but I’ve just never seen it…at least: not yet.) Due to how a cup of a mouthpiece is shaped, I’ve seen titanium coating failure down in there, which is why I’m not willing to coat the cups for customers. Further, it seems to me that the only practical reason for coating is for people who have really serious nickel allergies, as there is a 8% - 15% nickel in stainless steel (depending on the alloy). The face touches the rim. It’s difficult to imagine how a face could easily/routinely touch a mouthpiece cup interior. The main reason people ask for those coatings, though, is obviously for looks. Cups look like silver, and (the one particular color of) titanium coatings that we use on the rims looks like gold… except except they stay shiny, are extremely resistant to wear, and are resistant to scratching.
bloke “Titanium coatings can be applied in all sorts of wild colors, as has been seen on sports equipment and other things.”
Re: Skin issues on my upper lip
Since this popped back up, I'll give an update:
I have a new RT 88+ for the 12J, and a Blokepiece for my Kanstul. I haven't had an issue since I retired the old PT48. My dermatologist said it absolutely sounded like a brass sensitivity, and she suggested I use my psoriasis medicine on it whenever it happens. It definitely did help clear up the issues when it was there. As it is, I have only been practicing 2-3 hours a day right now, mainly to maintain my chops. Bass gigs have come back in full force, but tuba gigs are still here-and-there, but hoping that picks up more soon, too.
I have a new RT 88+ for the 12J, and a Blokepiece for my Kanstul. I haven't had an issue since I retired the old PT48. My dermatologist said it absolutely sounded like a brass sensitivity, and she suggested I use my psoriasis medicine on it whenever it happens. It definitely did help clear up the issues when it was there. As it is, I have only been practicing 2-3 hours a day right now, mainly to maintain my chops. Bass gigs have come back in full force, but tuba gigs are still here-and-there, but hoping that picks up more soon, too.
Nick
(This horn list more to remind me what I have than to brag)
1984 Conn 12J
1990s Kanstul 900-4B BBb
1924 Holton 122 Sousa
1972 Holton B300 Euph
If you see a Willson 2900, serial W2177, it's been missing for a long time. Help me bring it home.
(This horn list more to remind me what I have than to brag)
1984 Conn 12J
1990s Kanstul 900-4B BBb
1924 Holton 122 Sousa
1972 Holton B300 Euph
If you see a Willson 2900, serial W2177, it's been missing for a long time. Help me bring it home.